“Housing shortage – Jews to blame," letter sticker, German Reich, 1938 zwangsraeume.berlin/en/context
— Zach Everson (@zacheverson.com) November 13, 2025 at 6:16 PM
[image or embed]
If you haven’t been following administration messaging closely, you might have missed this. It hasn’t gotten nearly the coverage it deserves.
The White House and its allies are lining up behind the argument that mass deportation would reduce—or even eliminate—inflation.
There are a few deeply disturbing aspects to this. First, the history of this particular argument is exceptionally ugly, with clear antecedents in Nazi Germany.
Second there's the comically blatant lie of claiming that there thiry million undocumented imigrants living here.
Third—and here I’m a bit out of my depth, so I hope Joseph or some of our regulars will jump in if I get something wrong—it also runs directly counter to conventional economic theory. While removing millions of immigrants, documented and undocumented, would reduce demand, these workers are disproportionately employed in sectors like construction and food harvesting and processing. Access to immigrant labor also helps prevent severe labor shortages, which are themselves inflationary.
Fed Governor Stephen Miran: "Cutting down net migration to 0, potentially even negative because of the deportations that have been occurring, I think is very deflationary."
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) November 14, 2025 at 12:05 PM
[image or embed]
Perhaps the most disturbing part of all this (outside of the “we got it from the Nazis” angle) is hearing this line of argument coming from a fed governor. I doubt Miran believes what he’s saying here any more than Bessent believes the claims he’s been pushing about tariffs.
I'm not sure the dots connect here. The "wohnungsnot" sticker seems to show a farm woman, not an apartment tenant.
ReplyDeleteMy grandmother lived in a small farming town in Bavaria. My mother is convinced that she voted for Hitler. The big scandal that everyone was hearing about at the time was farm foreclosure. The farms in places like Marktoberdorf, Germany had mostly been owned by the same families for generations, all recorded in the records held at the church. By the 1920s and 30s, families that ran into financial trouble had to take out bank loans. Corruption at the highest levels of government resulted in collusion with the bankers, leading to a situation where the banks did whatever they could to make sure the loans could not be paid back, resulting in foreclosure. My grandmother and her peers were horrified at the number of families that had been dispossessed and thrown from their homes. The bankers were mostly Jewish.
My grandmother knew neither Jews nor bankers, but she hated them both nonetheless for this reason. You don't really hear about this kind of stuff nowadays.